BIOBaby: Breastfeeding at 48 Months
April 20, 2010 by nina
Filed under Blog It Out, Baby, Featured
My cousin had a baby in July of 2008. I gave birth to Jack in August of 2008. A few months ago we were both invited to a hookah bar and my response was, “I can’t go! I’m still breastfeeding!” Her response was, “So am I. Now, what’s your excuse?”
The big difference here is that she she was referring to her second child born since July 2008! That’s right. In the time it took her to nurse one child, wean him, get pregnant and have another baby, I’m still breastfeeding the same baby. And you know what? I think it downright offends some people. I’ve received eye rolls and head shakes and that’s from family!
When I was pregnant I said that I would breastfeed for the first two years. It seemed like a good length of time, and I suppose part of that decision was based on the guilt I felt for weaning Kali earlier than I’d planned. I left myself open to the possibility that I’d change my mind once I actually began.
Last February, when Jack was about six months old, my mother moved in with us. She is from the old school of feeding a baby pretty much anything that won’t choke ‘em and chewing up and feeding them the things that might. I was making Jack’s baby food myself (pureeing and freezing ice cube trays of carrots, squash, and apples) and as she made sure he was eating three squares (literally) a day, he seemed to become disinterested in nursing.
Oh, hell no. I increased my efforts, offering him the boob whenever I could, and it worked. He was back, firmly nestled in my breast where he belonged. A few more months passed and I thought 18-months-old might be a good place to stop. Then one day while on the phone with Sophie she asked when I was going to stop. I told her when Jack was 18 months. And she said, “Well, he’s 17-months-old now, you might wanna start weaning.”
Well, that was two months ago and I’m still “weaning.”
We tried the “don’t offer, don’t refuse” method. I wouldn’t offer up the booby during the day, but if he went for it, I wouldn’t refuse it either. I tried nursing only first thing in the morning, before nap time, and before bed at night. The problem was, he asked all the time!
And most times, he won’t even ask! I can be on the laptop, reading a book, watching T.V., or playing Halo and he’ll come and pull one out for a little pick-me-up. The boy has even pulled one out as I carried him on my hip, walking down the stairs. He literally lifted one out of my tank top, craned his neck, and started sucking.
“OK. You may need to start getting dressed everyday. No more wearing your P.J.s all day. No more tank tops. Start wearing turtlenecks tucked into your jeans… and wear a belt,” Sophie advised.
“Um, I think I need an armored vest!”
The majority of the time, I don’t mind that he’s still nursing. Sometimes it’s caused some pretty funny moments. Like, the other night when Jack and Donny were headed up to bed, and I decided to stay downstairs and watch Idol. Jack climbed out of my lap to follow Donny up the stairs. Just as he was about to climb up the first step he stopped, ran back to me, stood between my legs as I sat on the couch, pulled my nightshirt down and sucked, sucked, sucked, then ran back to Donny throwing a, “Bye!” over his shoulder. Donny said he just wanted “one for the road.”
Other times, it can be pretty inconvenient when he falls asleep and I have to carefully detach and then pray he doesn’t wake up as I transition him. And I’m pretty sure all these hormones are the reason behind my constant need to wax my face – but that’s for a whole ‘nother blog. I think what is worrying me is that I have no idea how to stop. A lot of people have said I should just let him decide. What if he decides he wants to be doing it till he’s 3? He’s already graduated from sippy cups to child cups with lids and straws, and recently he’s been pushing those aside and drinking from a lidless cup like a big boy, but he ain’t tryna give up the “bee bees.”
A lot of Moms who really advocate nursing will say, “You know, in other countries this isn’t such a big deal.”
Yeah, well, I live in America and I ain’t tryna be the mom squirting breastmilk in his thermos as he heads off to preschool!
Donny and I went to see 2012 and this trailer was shown before the movie. At the end of it, Donny turned to me and said, “That’s gonna be you and Jack.” No, it’s not! Right? RIGHT!?



Nina is a 34-year-old mother, wife and writer who spends her days blogging, studying, changing diapers and watching ridiculous amounts of TV. She currently resides in Atlanta, Georgia, with her husband, two children and three TiVos.




Hey dear. I thought I had commented this one a long time ago and never did so I will now.
Dont feel bad about EN. My cousin was still nursing her son to sleep and he is about 5. She just taught him that there is a time and place. For anytime she is going to give him milk, she has some leftover in the fridge that she warms up or she gives him regular milk.
Im actually quite curious whats she doing now that she is pregnant with her second child. I wonder if she is still nursing. I know some people arent able to nurse as easily while pregnant.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeBTW Hows back to school for Kali? And everything else going?
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI'm not going to read the comments because I've been dealing with negativity regarding EN (extended nursing) for many years now. I'm just going to say GOOD FOR YOU and it warms my heart to read this.
I recommend www.kellymom.com for child-led weaning advice. Bunch of damn hippies, though, I must warn you.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeThanks, Addie! I'll check it out.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeWell, as you know, my son is 23 months and still has a fixation on the morning nurse and the just before bed fill-up (which is actually very short. It's totally a comfort thing). He is as dedicated to these, however, as Charlton Heston was to his guns (something about prying them from cold, dead hands?). I do not have an answer because I'm still looking for one myself. the only solution I can think of is to have my husband get up with him in the morning and be the last one in the room at night for a solid week...and that week will be one of living hell. I think we might have to do it on his vacation. But maybe he'll surprise me, too.
J
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI'm not into breastfeeding so I can't comment on that aspect of it. And I couldn't care less whether or not you kept breastfeeding til he was 25. But personally, I feel that at 4 (maybe even 2 or 3), the baby is now a person and I wouldn't feel like i'm feeding a baby, I'd feel like a person is sucking on my tit. I'd be worried dateline would show up. You are never the same after Dateline shows up at your house.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI leaked milk reading it and I haven't in a little more than a year.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Likedang this blog made my boobs ache and I haven't breastfed in 3 years.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeFirst off I'm amazed that you really stuck to breastfeeding for 18 months. Jack is probably giong to be invincible. that's all I got, I have no kids, and am terrified at the prospect of parenting.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeYeah, I'm thinking he owes me big time.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI applaud you for hanging in as long as you have. My first born wouldn't latch on properly, and my last two I weaned them off my I went back to work. Not one month after I went back to work, my dept got laid off, so I was pretty upset that I had weaned Madison off for no reason. You and Jack will know when the time is right, Good Luck!!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeGood luck. lol
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeWell Nina, I am the mother of five, my first I did not breastfood. the other four I did. Brandon is my first breastfeed baby and I swear the boy never wanted to wean. Finally in frustration I put tabasco sauce on the nipple. Let me tell you, it burned like hell! My poor baby, when ever he would approachme to nurse, I would remind him that chi chi milk is hot. He would fan his mouth and say, oh no, burn. I am so guilty, needless to say weaning did not get any easier with any of my kids, I was always jealous of the moms whose kids just weaned themselves. I say on utube this 9 year girl still nursed, and her mom was fine with it. p.s. still working on weaning the last one. sheesh..
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI am not against breastfeeding. It is natural, that is why our bodies produce the milk, therefore there must be a benefit to it. My theory is (and I am not a mom) that breastfeeding is for when the kid can't eat real food. Once they get teeth and start graduating to other foods, I think the necessity to breastfeed is gone. As for how to stop, I am not a mom, I never did it, and I got nothing to add.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Like"Your son is cute. How old is he?"
"He's 48 months."
"That's FOUR."
"Uh huh."
LMFAO!!!!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI have nothing constructive to say I just like reading about boobies.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Likeso here is my words of wisdom...wean him off the TITTIES first...by that I mean start pumping, when he goes to grab your shirt tell him no and hand him a cup with some boobie juice in it. Thats how I did Dei, she never got boobs during the day, only at night, and then once she started sleeping through the night my milk dried up.
You really do need to set boundries, I still have to tell Deijah to leave my boobs alone because she will smush and push them into "che che pillows" when we are watching tv together. I finally had to tell her that it was inappropriate to just grab someones boobs...of course her smart-ass answer was "i dont grab anyones boobs mommy, just yours because i love you and they are comfortable"
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI can tell you right now: that ain't gonna work. First off, I'm not pumping a damn thing. I barely have time now to do anything! Second, he already looks at me like I've bumped my head when I try to offer him a cup over boob.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeExactly! I am currently nursing my toddler, and the situation is similar to what you have described, I would like to be done with it but don't want to FORCE him to stop, ideally he will stop soon or at least go down to once a day. I am definitely not pumping, that is way to intensive for me, I started and kept nursing because it was EASY!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI like Steph's advice.
I also don't want to see you on a documentary in 10 years.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI've had employers nurse for two years and beyond, and it does shock or offend some people, but usually because they either 1) chose not to nurse at all and have zero understanding; or 2) they had a less than desirable time nursing due to complications, allergies, they were a slave to the pump, etc.
Only one employer had to start restricting and began weaning only at night, replacing it with a soy milk, and within a month her daughter simply never even made an attempt.
Of course, she was 26 months and fully talking. We went to the aquarium and she saw a mother nursing her 6 month old, walked up to her and busted out with "I only drink nipples at night now!!"...and she said it kind of pissy like she got the shaft!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeLMAO! I can totally hear that.
I'll get serious about it when I'm ready. Obviously, I'm not ready and neither is he. I can just imagine the look of resentment he'll give me if I try to stop before he's ready. You should have seen his face today when I ate all of a granola bar w/o giving him any.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeWhile I am VERY pro breastfeeding. I do think Jack is old enough to learn private space. If he wants to nurse, nurse him, but don't make it so damn convenient.
No more one for the road. If he wants to eat he needs to stop what he is doing and eat, if only for 5 or 10 minutes. This will also encourage good eating behaviors for later in life, eat when you are hungry, stop when you are not. When he just lifts your shirt, gently pull it down and ask if he is hungry, if yes, then pick him up and feed him, if no then just snuggle him for a minute and send him on his way. When he is 6 you are not going to let him just open the cabinets and eat a pack of gummy snacks 4 times a day.
He realizes now that your milk is way sweeter than anything else he gets to drink.
You have to ultimately do what you are comfortable with. He is your baby. If you want to nurse until he is 6 I am happy for ya. Seriously.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeSomething tells me that Jack will never be one of those children whom you have to fight with to get them to eat.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeThat is SO you and Jack, only the boy in the trailer asked first. Jack doesn't. He is so gangsta!!!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI love how Salma Hayek covers her kid's eyes. LMAO
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Like